Metals are used in primary producer metabolic pathways, such as photosynthesis and the acquisition of macronutrients nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P), yet we often do not know their potential as limiting nutrients in freshwaters. In the Great Lakes, metals have sometimes been identified as limiting the acquisition of macronutrients, mostly in off-shore waters that are relatively isolated from tributary inputs and sediment interactions. We hypothesized that another area where metals might be important was within harmful algal blooms (HABs). Harmful algal blooms are more likely to occur where N and P loads are elevated due to human activities, but short-term growth assays still often find summer bloom communities are N or P limited due to high biotic demand. This high biotic is associated with rapid nutrient recycling which may increase demand for trace metals beyond the available supply. A relatively common cyanotoxin (microcystin) has also been hypothesized to have a role in trace metal management, so trace metal demand may also influence the toxicity of bloom communities. Here, we used nutrient diffusing substrates to measure the magnitude of macronutrient and trace metal effects on growth and toxicity of biofilms suspended in 10 nearshore sites in Lake Michigan and Lake Erie (5 with and 5 without perennial HABs). We measured microcystin, chlorophyll a, ash free dry mass and community composition on the experimental biofilms.